A Montana jury recently rejected a “stand your ground” defense offered by a defendant charge with the murder of a German exchange student earlier this year. The defendant argued that he was only acting out of self-defense in protecting his home against intrusion by burglars, but the jury instead found…
Massachusetts Criminal Defense Lawyer Blog
Washington Appeals Court address Right to Remain Silent in recent decision
The Constitution protects us when we make statements under police interrogation without being advised of our rights, or when we decide not to make any statements at all. One of the key rights stated in a Miranda warning is the right to remain silent. This right guarantees that a defendant…
Hernandez defense team attempts to block evidence of prior criminal behavior from trial
Aaron Hernandez’s defense attorneys are once again asking the trial court to prevent the prosecution from raising certain evidence against Hernandez during his murder trial in the Fall River Superior Court. In particular, FOX25 News reports that the motion seeks to exclude eight separate instances of the defendant’s past behavior…
Supreme Court hears Fourth Amendment challenge to warrantless police searches of hotel guest lists
The U.S. Supreme Court has agreed to hear the City of Los Angeles’ appeal of a Ninth Circuit decision holding that a city ordinance requiring hotels to maintain detailed records of each guest’s identity and personal information unconstitutional. In a split decision, the Ninth Circuit found the ordinance to violate…
United States Supreme Court to determine whether threats are protected free speech under First Amendment
Many crimes require proof that the defendant specifically intended to cause the harm alleged by the crime. In Massachusetts, obtaining a civil harassment protective order requires the complainant to prove that the defendant intentionally placed someone in fear of harm using their words or acts. Just recently, however, the Supreme…
Marijuana Breath Tests in Development at Washington State University may result in increased OUI Drugs arrests
A Washington State University professor is currently developing the first portable breathalyzer that tests for marijuana substance consumed by a driver. Washington law enforcement agencies are particularly enthusiastic about the test, as more and more drivers are operating while under the influence of marijuana in one of only two states…
United States Supreme Court may address whether statements to mandatory reports are testimonial under the Confrontation Clause
The U.S. Supreme Court will soon determine whether it will hear an appeal on the 6th Amendment Confrontation Clause rights of a defendant convicted of assault and domestic violence on his girlfriend’s children. The petition requesting Supreme Court review was filed by the State of Ohio after the Ohio Supreme…
Judge’s Decision in Etan Patz Case Highlights the Significance of False Confessions
A recent decision in New York has highlighted the role of false confessions in a case outcome. New York judge, Maxwell Wiley, has ruled a confession admissible despite the defendant’s low IQ and the lengthy duration of the interrogation process. The Confession Pedro Hernandez, who was 19 at the time,…
Should I testify at my DUI Trial?
The two most difficult decisions for any Massachusetts OUI Attorney are typically: Should the client testify; & should we elect a bench or jury trial. In this Blog, I will discuss the decision whether or not to testify at trial. When preparing for trial, a client will have some piece…
Fourth Amendment challenge to breath test refusal statute rejected by Appellate Court
Most drivers don’t realize that every state requires a driver suspected of drunk driving submit to a blood-alcohol test or face mandatory license suspension. This requirement is outlined in “implied-consent statutes.” Although the U.S. Supreme Court has partially addressed the constitutionality of these statutes, a recent defendant in Illinois unsuccessfully…